


Today, I realized that the induction ceremony for the Pro Football Hall Of Fame is only a month away. While this year’s class is strong and impressive, I can’t help but to think about two people that should have been wearing that yellow jacket years ago! I can’t help but to wonder why Art Monk and Roger Craig are not in the Hall of Fame when they have contirbuted more than their share to the league and their teams.
Despite being eclipsed by Rice, Carter, Brown and Reed in the record books, Monk’s resume is still impeccable! Monk was the first WR to reach 900 career receptions (940), amassed 12,721 career receiving yards, 68 touchdowns, and most important, three Super Bowl rings (XVII,XXII,XXVI). Currently, no receiver in the Hall Of Fame have more catches,yards, and titles* than Monk. While statistics play a huge part in selection, impact on a team plays even a bigger part. With that said,no one could deny the enormous impact that Art Monk had on the Washington Redskins during the 1980’s.
While Gary Clark and Ricky Sanders received all the attention from the media and scared defensive coordinators, Monk was the man behind the Smurfs’/Posse’s success. This is so because Monk was the inside receiver that most defenses focused on thus leaving Clark or Sanders open for the 50 yard bomb. Monk was catalyst of that receiving corp because he did what was necessary to make Joe Gibbs’ offense one of the most feared and potent in the league. He was the guy that ran routes accross the middle, moved the chains in third down situations to open up opportunities for John Riggins and Earnest Byner. Speaking of the running game, Monk’s blocking was top notch and it helped the running backs gain considerable yards beyond the line of scrimmage.
For all the hard work and stats over the years, all Monk gets is rejections and a 46 minute discussion among voting sportswriters about his importance!(Peter King, Monday Morning ,QB Nov. 2005). If that isnt insulting enough, there are a few Monk naysayers that implied that he is overlooked because he didnt make a spectacular catch or huge play in the Super Bowl or conference championship games like Lynn Swann did ( Leonard Shapiro, A Hall Of Mystery, Feb. 2005)
If all it took to get in the Hall of Fame as a receiver was to make some eye popping, flashy catches and big plays, why did it take Swann 14 years after eligibilty to get in? If flash is all it takes for receivers, why isn’t Clark and Sanders considered for the hall? If it is simply flash that some of these sportscasters want from their Hall Of Fame receivers, then what is Steve Largent doing in Canton? As far as big plays are concerned, where is Dwight Clark’s bust?
Michael Irvin may have the WR slot for this years class. However, Monk should be wearing the yellow jacket no earlier than next August or in 2009. After ‘09, his chances may be even slimmer because Jerry Rice, Tim Brown, and Cris Carter will be eligible in 2010 at the earliest. Since 2010 will be stacked with WR’s, you all might as well vote Monk, Rice, Brown,Carter, and Reed in at one time and call it a day.
On the other hand, you can be a great player and even an intrigal part of a revolutionary offense and not even be on the Hall of Fame Ballot. Forty Niner great Roger Craig have been eligible for the hall since 1998 and no one in the selection comittee is giving him the time of day. While his stats may not be as gaudy and Walter Payton’s, Barry Sanders’ and Emmitt Smith’s, Roger Craig had a significant impact on the game. You all must have forgot that Craig is the innovator of the modern day running back-a double threat on the ground and through the air! This guy was the first running back to gain more than 1,000 yards rushing and 1,000 yards recieving in a season.(1985) In 1988, Craig reached and broke the 2,000 combined yardage mark for the second time in his 11 year career. In additon to being elected to the Pro Bowl at both halfback and fullback, Craig also remains the only running back to lead the league in receiptions and the only one to record 100 yards receiving in the Super Bowl.
Remember when I mentioned that some sportswriters and sportscasters implied that a big play was needed? Well, who you think kept the Niners’ hopes alive during the closing minutes of Super Bowl XXIII with his opening catch and two runs? While that sequence was remembered for John Taylor’s winning TD, it was Craig along with Jerry Rice that helped the Niners overcome a pontentally devistaing penality by Randy Cross.
Simply put, Roger Craig was just as infuluental in the Niner dynasty as Walsh, Montana, Rice, Lott, and Clark, and his respect and his HOF nod is long overdue. Don’t get me wrong, he was playing in the huge shadow of arugueably the greatest quarterback, receiver and safety to ever play, and overlooking the contributions is easy. However, those contributions are worthy for at least consideration.
* NOTE: The titles statement is among those already in Hall. Irvin has 3 himself but he is not offically enshrined.